2 Replies Latest reply on Oct 20, 2015 1:37 AM by hawaiiuser

    FirePro W8100 - Terribly low performance with ECC

    hawaiiuser

      Greetings,

       

      I experience a serious performance decrease with the AMD FirePro W8100, if I enable the Error-Correcting Code.

       

      While all of the attached images are from synthethic tests, for the easier reproduction, the real-world numbers are almost the same. I tried all available drivers, today I installed the newest Catalyst Pro, but the same performance drop remained.

      Otherwise my system is very stable, and I have no issues with any 3d-applications.

       

      I doubt that this is normal, so either is something wrong with my card or is this a driver or operating-system related issue which can be adressed in the future?

      (Currently I'm using Windows 7 Ultimate x64 SP1 with the latest updates.)

       

      Please help resolving this problem.

      Thanks.

        • Re: FirePro W8100 - Terribly low performance with ECC
          fsadough

          This is by design. When you enable ECC you will have less graphics memory available . Please click on the green ? on ECC page in the Catalyst Control Center to read about ECC.

            • Re: FirePro W8100 - Terribly low performance with ECC
              hawaiiuser

              Yes, I know that the available memory is reduced, but not too much (less than 1 GB), the memory bandwidth is also reduced (about 23% less with ECC, according to AIDA 64 GPGPU benchmark).

               

              What I'm trying to say is that applications runs much slower with ECC, even those, which do not require 7-8 GB of VRAM or high memory bandwidth,

               

              If you open my attached images, in the LuxMark HDR test, I got 13388 points without ECC (rays/second 29951K), which is normal for a HAWAII GPU, but with ECC, it is only 1610 (rays/second 3623K), Almost ten times slower.

              RatGPU finished under 149 seconds, with ECC it was 738 seconds.

              And I know, this is not a gaming card**, but if you see the 6 years old Stalker CoP benchmark results, the performance difference is also very huge, it's not just about GPGPU, it affects a lot of applications,

              Without ECC, 3ds max is butter smooth with 10+ million polys, sometimes even parallel with Vray RT activeshade, depending on the scene, but when I enable ECC, I experience slowdown from about 1.5-2 million polygons, and this is without activeshade, just in the viewport.

              Currently the only program what I'm tested and don't saw any performance difference was the old SpecViewPerf 11 synthetic (OpenGL based?) test.

               

              (**Rarely I'm doing gaming too, and the card handles even GTA V without any performance or image quality issue with high- very high settings at 1080p.)

               

                

              I just want to know that is this by design too, or if isn't, then maybe a driver/OS or a hardware issue with my card?