cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

General Discussions

kingfish
MVP

MSI Launches a Water-Cooled Motherboard That Won’t Break the Bank

MSI-Z490-Carbon-MPG-Feature

Back in early May, we discussed Asrock’s $1,100 motherboard and the fact that it didn’t seem to be designed for any actual group of users. Now, MSI has announced its own water-cooling product line, and it looks to be considerably more practical than what Asrock showed in May.

The MSI MPG Z490 Carbon EK X (MPG? Carbon?) features a custom water block built in partnership with the premium water block manufacturer EKWB. The cooler block is designed to cool both the CPUs and VRMs, which means it’ll fit this motherboard specifically but won’t work with others unless MSI goes to the trouble of guaranteeing backwards-and-forwards water block compatibility.

Feature-wise, the board supports what you’d expect from a product of its caliber, with USB 3.2 Gen 2×2, Wi-Fi 6, and 2.5G Ethernet support. The motherboard includes a leak-testing kit and RGB support done in MSI’s colors with support for 16.8 million colors and 29 effects. With this kind of color and effect support, you can keep it looking like a unicorn horked a rainbow into your office all year round.

Price: Reasonable!

The biggest reason I didn’t like Asrock’s shot at the water-cooled market is that it wasn’t clear who was actually supposed to buy an $1100 motherboard as a serious product. When fully custom kits from EKWB cost less than half that much, asking consumers to shuck out that kind of cash for a motherboard takes some guts, whether the product in question is “limited edition” or not.

MSI-MPG-Carbon

Thankfully, MSI doesn’t follow Asrock’s lead in the pricing department. The MSI MPG Z490 Carbon EK X is expected to retail for just $399, and while that’s still quite high, it’s much closer to something enthusiasts might consider reasonable than $1,100 was.

Will This Trend Hold?

The most interesting thing about the fact that we’re seeing multiple companies pushing custom loop solutions as default on a motherboard is the implication that this could become more common in years ahead. AMD and Intel’s power consumption isn’t going down, and power demands are only increasing.

To put it another way: If Intel or AMD kicks a 500W CPU out the door and declares it’s for top-tier water-cooling enthusiasts, you’d see a spike in custom loop sales.

Nothing within realistic reach of a conventional PC enthusiast can trump custom loop water cooling with an internal or external reservoir. Single-stage freon cooling is much colder, of course, but not many people have the expertise to build one. EKWB, in contrast, sells prebuilt water cooling kits to take all the guesswork out of the equation.

I think the chances of this happening are still quite small, the PC industry has never collectively embraced water cooling, preferring to instead find ways to further extend air cooling performance. If absolute PC power consumption keeps increasing, they won’t have a choice. With that said, water delivers excellent results on the whole. When I reviewed the VisionTek CryoVenom back in 2014, I was astonished to see how well the GCN GPU responded to high clocks — from 949MHz to 1225MHz, at a maximum temperature of just 46 degrees Celsius. Water definitely has cooling potential that air can’t match, but whether we’ll see it catch on in the mainstream market? That’s a different story.

MSI Launches a Water-Cooled Motherboard That Won't Break the Bank - ExtremeTech 

5 Replies

Re: MSI Launches a Water-Cooled Motherboard That Won’t Break the Bank

Are they sure the $399 price is right?  This is the same company who flogs $700 motherboards after all...

0 Likes
kingfish
MVP

Re: MSI Launches a Water-Cooled Motherboard That Won’t Break the Bank

Damifino! Here's another:

MSI MPG Z490 Carbon EK X: LGA1200 Motherboard with an EKWB Monoblock 

The Core i9-10900K is a hot CPU, even at stock, and with the performance gained via Intel's Thermal Velocity Boost, performance cooling is more important than it ever has. There are only a handful of Z490 models that include water blocks, and they aren't cheap. The ASRock Z490 Aqua is $1100, while the GIGABYTE Z490 Aorus Xtreme WaterForce is $1299. This model is expected to retail for $400.

Re: MSI Launches a Water-Cooled Motherboard That Won’t Break the Bank

You know what they say about things which sound too good to be true...and what they say about Might Suddenly Implode...Still, figuring that AMD's Ryzen 3000 series has the Intel 10000 series trumped in every way from power to performance to features, they have to do something to get people outside the die hard Intel fanboy club to buy them. The only downside is that you won't be able to use Thermaltake's new AIO which also cools your RAM...

hardcoregames_
Big Boss

Re: MSI Launches a Water-Cooled Motherboard That Won’t Break the Bank

Cooling the memory is hardly needed these days. DDR4 sticks are 11.85 W for 4 sticks like I use. My chassis fans have that covered easily.

0 Likes
pokester
MVP

Re: MSI Launches a Water-Cooled Motherboard That Won’t Break the Bank

If it comes out at that price and is also stable and reliable that will be a big seller at that price. 

0 Likes