12 Replies Latest reply on Jun 4, 2016 10:30 AM by black_zion

    AMD responds to AotS 2x RX 480 vs 1x GTX 1080 benchmark results (and lobs a shell at nVidia)

    black_zion

      AMD exec discusses Radeon RX 480 Ashes of the Singularity demo - Graphics - News - HEXUS.net

       

       

      Concerning the AOTS image quality controversy

      Hi. Now that I'm off of my 10-hour airplane ride to Oz, and I have reliable internet, I can share some insight.

      System specs:

      • CPU: i7 5930K
      • RAM: 32GB DDR4-2400Mhz
      • Motherboard: Asrock X99M Killer
      • GPU config 1: 2x Radeon RX 480 @ PCIE 3.0 x16 for each GPU
      • GPU config 2: Founders Edition GTX 1080
      • OS: Win 10 64bit
      • AMD Driver: 16.30-160525n-230356E
      • NV Driver: 368.19
      • In Game Settings for both configs: Crazy Settings | 1080P | 8x MSAA | VSYNC OFF
      • Ashes Game Version: v1.12.19928

      Benchmark results:

      2x Radeon RX 480 - 62.5 fps | Single Batch GPU Util: 51% | Med Batch GPU Util: 71.9 | Heavy Batch GPU Util: 92.3% GTX 1080 – 58.7 fps | Single Batch GPU Util: 98.7%| Med Batch GPU Util: 97.9% | Heavy Batch GPU Util: 98.7%

      The elephant in the room:

      Ashes uses procedural generation based on a randomized seed at launch. The benchmark does look slightly different every time it is run. But that, many have noted, does not fully explain the quality difference people noticed.

      At present the GTX 1080 is incorrectly executing the terrain shaders responsible for populating the environment with the appropriate amount of snow. The GTX 1080 is doing less work to render AOTS than it otherwise would if the shader were being run properly. Snow is somewhat flat and boring in color compared to shiny rocks, which gives the illusion that less is being rendered, but this is an incorrect interpretation of how the terrain shaders are functioning in this title.

      The content being rendered by the RX 480--the one with greater snow coverage in the side-by-side (the left in these images)--is the correct execution of the terrain shaders.

      So, even with fudgy image quality on the GTX 1080 that could improve their performance a few percent, dual RX 480 still came out ahead.

      As a parting note, I will mention we ran this test 10x prior to going on-stage to confirm the performance delta was accurate. Moving up to 1440p at the same settings maintains the same performance delta within +/-1%.

       

      Sacrificing IQ for FPS, where have we heard this before...