cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Processors

markozawr
Adept I

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

So AIDA64 shows tCTL temperature for CPU?

0 Kudos
hardcoregames_
Big Boss

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

markozawr wrote:

Do you mean Tmax 91C for Tdie or tCTL?

Tmax applies to the sensors on the die and it the AIDA report it shows 71C which is not bad for the TR4 platform

0 Kudos
defalkner
Adept I

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

One problem with AIDA is that it shows values but their nonsense as far as a description and causes confusion. Here is a description for Tctl directly from AMD
   "The primary temperature reporting sensor of the AMD Ryzen™ processor is a sensor called “T Control,” or tCTL for short. The tCTL sensor is derived from the junction (Tj) temperature—the interface point between the die and heatspreader—but it may be offset on certain CPU models so that all models on the AM4 Platform have the same maximum tCTL value. This approach ensures that all AMD Ryzen™ processors have a consistent fan policy."

Threadripper uses a +27°C offset. So average temp of the dies is 43°C but to make sure fans are running 'fast enough', fan curves should use the 70°C mark. Your CPU is really 44c during idle - so your perfectly fine. and doing fantastic. 

Mine is idling right now (no OC) /w a 360mm radiator at 36c (Tdie) & 63c (Tctl)  -beautiful. Here's a screen shot of HWINFO64 using my data for you to see.

000141.jpg

hardcoregames_
Big Boss

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

I run my front fan at 100% from a setting in the BIOS which is best I can do for cooling my box. Rear exhaust fans at max are not quite as effective. 

Try front fans at max and see how your box fairs

0 Kudos
markozawr
Adept I

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

Thank you for a worthy answer. Appreciated it! That's what I needed to know.

0 Kudos
ad_ws_tx
Adept I

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

If it makes you sleep better at night I'll share the following story about my 1950x.  I use it for long (days long...) simulation jobs using all 16 cores.  One night the water cooling pump failed.  The system shut down.

In troubleshooting the issue the CPU went to overtemp and shut down a few more times until I understood what was going on.  Installed replacement cooler and machine took off right as rain.

That was 7 months ago.  7 months of hard use.  I mean everything will break eventually, and this is just my one experience with this one particular chip, but I don't think you have anything to worry about.

Best,

misterj
Exemplar

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

I have decided to comment because there is so much disinformation being distributed.  I, of course am a User and do not work for AMD.  Being confused by all the strange information, I opened an AMD Online Support request and asked for definitions of all the temperature terms.  Here is what I found:

The only application that gives an accurate report of temperature is Ryzen Master (RM).

There is no offset.  Used to be but no more - just confused Users.

There is a specification for each processor that includes the maximum temperature.  This is what the SoC uses to throttle the processor and ultimately shut it down.  Here is the one for the 1950X:

pastedImage_1.jpg

What is given above is fact gleaned from the information supplied by AMD.  Please open your own Ticket if you like.

Now for some of my opinion:

AIDA64 is by far the best application for measuring temperature, voltages, currents and power for Ryzen.  FinalWire (company behind AIDA64) is a Partner of AMD, allowing sharing of information.  I use it and display what AIDA64 calls 'CPU Diode' for the 2990WX.  It is actually tCtl and agrees with RM.  Of course, all users can use whatever application they like to do this, but I suggest they compare its results to RM for validation.

Enjoy, John.

0 Kudos
defalkner
Adept I

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

Jon You could have just opened Wikipedia. Its the same for AMD & intel. The fact the support told you Ryzen Master is the only accurate way to get temps is not accurate and misinformation by itself - am I not able to trust the temps in BIOS? (Ryzen Master is reporting Tdie btw) Of course that's what their TOLD to tell you because it's a fast easy answer. God forbid you have Linux server since Ryzen Master is only available for Windows. Many users use AIDA64 because it's the only application they have experience with. In my earlier post I made it very clear the problem with AIDA64 is the lack of information - when your seeing CPU DIODE, what sensor is it specifically? Who knows! (Another reason I do not recommend AIDA64) It's not going to help me as an IT when there is 36 thermal sensors on a Threadripper not knowing which one specifically I am looking at wile AIDA is showing me 2 values if I'm lucky, while using non-industry standard terminology. Why all the missing ACPI thermal sensors? 

The Tier 1 support didn't know what they were talking about (not surprising). There is an offset - the CPU tells us this because its reporting Tctl. Is my SMBus/I2C just making up information? Not all AMD CPU's have this value and not all software knows how to interpret this (AIDA64 for example) Threadripper IS 27c period and it IS used unless AMD engineers were lying and confused (Ill have a link below for you)... I think your support was confused. Its there primarily for servers to compensate as an AMBIENT temperature offset for the fan speed controller on the motherboard. That's it. I think your confused when AMD says tctl is not used, no it's not used for thermal throttling but it IS used by the motherboard. I already posted screen shots of RAW values in HWinfo64 which gets weekly builds. The issues users were having was 'why' is the CPU so hot when they were mistakenly looking at Tctl when they needed to be looking at Tdie. That was it. Users generally only need to be concerned about Tdie - period. Nobody said anything else so your drawing your own assumptions. 

Your gleaned screen shot was cute. Everyone already knows this. I couldn't have been more clear in my previous posts. Let me ask you this - what does the max temp mean to you? What could it possibly mean to me as an IT? If 68c is the maximum for the CPU, why does it not thermal shutdown? In fact why does the CPU only begin to throttle after 80c? And TJMax is over 100c? Now I understand your just an everyday user, but your making assumptions without all the information here. A perfect example why AMD needs an ARK database like intel (highly detailed CPU specifications database). What if my memory controller was running 70.5c but the die only reporting 66c in Ryzen Master? Is my CPU overheating? The value AMD posts is a required Tcase value. The value is the maximum temperature for the IHS, not the die. You would know this if you educated yourself more on what these values mean (theres a website called Wikipedia that might help you) instead of coming in and lecturing everyone after a single ticket with a tier 1 tech (lowest level) and declaring were confused and misinformed when you dont even know what the values your looking at even mean. 

Let me help you out - here is Steve from GamersNexus (highly respected and qualified) discussing the tctl temperature offset with information he got from - you guessed it!  AMD engineers.  Shows how much your tech agent knew.
Ask GN 56: AMD TCTL - YouTube 

misterj
Exemplar

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

defalkner, enjoy.  You are welcome to believe anything you desire - it is everyone's basic right.  I am NOT confused!  Hope you have a good day.  Enjoy, John.

0 Kudos
elstaci
MVP

Re: Threadripper 1950X - Max Temps

I have shown the other User links showing that AMD Processor Spec concerning MAX TEMP is not the temperature where the CPU will shutdown.

The Max Temp on the Spec is indicating the MAXIMUM "OPERATING" TEMPERATURE of the Processor. Once the processor's temperature is reaching MAX or at MAX TEMP, the Processor automatically starts to throttle to prevent it from overheating or running hotter than the MAX TEMP. If unable to to keep the temperature below MAX and continues rising it will eventually reach a certain temperature where the CPU will shut down to prevent damage.

This 3DGURU verifies what you are saying: AMD Ryzen Threadripper 1950X review - Power Consumption & Temperatures 

Also this previous LinusTechTips thread also verifies what you mentioned: https://linustechtips.com/main/topic/817930-1950x-max-temp/ 

0 Kudos